Hormones, Hunger and Mystery Weight Gain

Why menopause can leave you craving everything in the kitchen while your waistline seems to be doing its own thing.

You're eating pretty much what you've always eaten.
You're not suddenly living on takeaways and family-sized bars of chocolate.
And yet your jeans are getting tighter, the scales are creeping upwards and by about 8pm you're wondering whether there's anything worth eating left in the cupboards.
Sound familiar?
Welcome to one of the more frustrating parts of midlife.
Is it your hormones? Your metabolism? Are you eating too much? Or has your body simply decided to stop cooperating?
The answer isn't always straightforward. And that's exactly why I think we need to talk about it.
First, let's talk about those hormones
During perimenopause and menopause, oestrogen levels fluctuate and eventually decline.
Those changes can affect where your body stores fat, with many women noticing more around their middle than they used to.
And here's something worth understanding:
You can experience changes in your body shape without a dramatic increase in your weight.
Fat distribution can change, muscle mass can decline with age, and the body you see in the mirror may start looking different even when the scales haven't changed much.
But menopause isn't automatically responsible for every extra pound.
Ageing, changes in activity levels, sleep, eating habits and how much energy your body needs all play a part.
It's not as simple as “my hormones are making me fat”, but it's equally unhelpful to tell women that nothing has changed and they should just eat less.
Something has changed. We need to understand the whole picture.
So why am I suddenly hungry all the time?
Let's start with a question.
What have you actually eaten today?
Not what you planned to eat. What you've really eaten.
Maybe breakfast was coffee and a slice of toast because you were rushing.
Lunch was a small salad because you're trying to be good.
Then dinner arrives, you eat a perfectly reasonable meal, and an hour later you're back in the kitchen looking for something sweet.
It's easy to blame a lack of willpower.
But you may simply not have eaten enough satisfying food throughout the day.
If your meals are consistently low in protein, fibre or overall energy, it's hardly surprising if you're hungry later.
And this is where I see women make things unnecessarily difficult for themselves.
They want to lose weight, so they start making every meal smaller.
They're hungry, so they try harder to resist eating.
Then evening arrives and they're absolutely ravenous.
Sometimes the answer isn't another diet. It's looking at whether your meals are actually keeping you satisfied.
And what about those cravings?
Let's get something straight.
Wanting chocolate doesn't mean your hormones are broken.
And eating a biscuit doesn't mean you've ruined your diet.
Cravings can happen for all sorts of reasons. Hunger, habits, stress, tiredness, food restrictions and simply enjoying certain foods can all play a part.
But there's another piece of the midlife puzzle worth looking at.
Sleep.
If you're waking up several times a night, throwing the duvet off because you're boiling hot, then dragging yourself through the following day, managing your food choices can feel much harder.
Research suggests that insufficient sleep can increase food intake, although its effects on hunger and appetite vary between people.
So if you're constantly exhausted and craving something sweet by late afternoon, perhaps the first question shouldn't be “How do I get more disciplined?”
Perhaps it should be “How much sleep am I actually getting, and am I eating enough during the day?”
And sometimes you just fancy chocolate.
That's allowed too.
The metabolism question
Ah yes, metabolism.
Apparently, according to half the internet, yours fell off a cliff the moment you turned 40.
Except that's not quite how it works.
Your body doesn't suddenly forget how to burn calories because you've reached a certain birthday.
However, as we get older, changes in muscle mass, activity and other factors can affect how much energy we use.
If you're moving less than you used to, spending more time sitting down and gradually losing muscle, your energy needs may be different.
Add in menopausal changes in fat distribution and you can begin to see why managing weight might feel harder than it once did.
But harder doesn't mean impossible. And it certainly doesn't mean you need to survive on lettuce leaves.
Right, so what can you actually do?
Rather than changing everything at once, here are five things I'd start looking at.
1. Stop treating breakfast and lunch like they're optional
If you're regularly starving by late afternoon, look at what you're eating earlier in the day.
Try building meals around a useful source of protein, alongside fibre-rich carbohydrates, fruit or vegetables and enough food to satisfy you.
For example, instead of just toast for breakfast, you could have eggs on toast with some fruit.
Or add a generous serving of high-protein yoghurt and berries to your usual breakfast.
Not because toast is bad. Because a more balanced meal may keep you satisfied for longer.
2. Don't save all your protein for dinner
Protein helps your body maintain and build muscle, especially when you're strength training.
It can also help meals feel more filling.
Try including a decent protein source at breakfast, lunch and dinner.
That might mean eggs, yoghurt, chicken, fish, tofu, beans or whatever suits the way you eat.
You don't have to live on protein shakes or start weighing every mouthful.
Just become a little more aware of what your meals contain.
3. Start building muscle, not just trying to burn calories
If your only response to gaining weight is to eat less and do more cardio, you're missing something important.
Muscle matters. Particularly as we get older.
Strength training helps maintain and build muscle, supports bone health and can improve strength and everyday function.
It also gives you another way to measure progress besides the scales.
You might notice you're lifting heavier weights, climbing stairs more easily or feeling stronger in everyday life.
You don't need to train every day. Two or three well-planned strength sessions a week can be a sensible approach for many women.
And if you're a beginner, you can start with exercises suited to your ability.
4. Look at your sleep before blaming your willpower
If you're regularly exhausted, take that seriously.
A consistent sleep routine may help, but if night sweats, anxiety or other menopause symptoms are keeping you awake, speak to your GP about treatment options.
You don't have to simply put up with feeling dreadful.
And remember that tiredness, stress and disrupted routines can make it harder to keep up the habits that support your health.
5. Stop judging everything by the number on the scales
The scales tell you how much you weigh.
They don't tell you how much muscle you have, how strong you are or how your fitness is improving.
If changing your body composition is your goal, pay attention to more than weight alone.
How are your clothes fitting?
Are your weights increasing?
Are you feeling stronger?
Are your habits becoming more consistent?
These things matter too.
One thing I'd really like women to understand
Not every change in your body is caused by menopause. But menopause can make some of those changes harder to manage.
And that distinction matters.
Because if we blame absolutely everything on hormones, it's easy to feel as though there's nothing we can do.
On the other hand, if we ignore the hormonal changes altogether, we're not acknowledging what many women are genuinely experiencing.
The sensible approach sits somewhere in the middle.
Understand what's changing.
Look at your nutrition, movement, strength training and sleep.
Get appropriate medical support when you need it.
And stop assuming the answer is another restrictive diet.
If your weight changes rapidly or unexpectedly, or your hunger is unusually persistent, it's worth speaking with your GP rather than assuming menopause is the cause.
A final thought
You don't need to spend the rest of your life fighting your appetite, avoiding foods you enjoy or desperately trying to get back into the body you had at 25.
But you can work towards feeling stronger, healthier and more comfortable in the body you have now.
And if there's one thing I've learnt from over 25 years of coaching women, it's that the basics still matter.
Eat well. Build muscle. Move regularly. Get support when you need it. And find an approach you can actually live with.
It might not sound as exciting as the latest hormone-balancing miracle being advertised online.
But it's a much better place to start.
Jill Laws PT
Helping women over 40 build strength, confidence and healthier habits.




Comments